anythingbutgrey | HARRY POTTER NON-CANON SHIPS COMMENT FICATHON

Banner by operatingroom

Harry Potter Non-Canon Ships Comment Ficathon

THE RULES ARE THUS:

1. WHAT MAKES A NON-CANON SHIP? Anything that is not at least one-sided in the books. This means that Snape/Lily is canon, even if she may (or may not) have ever reciprocated. Bellatrix/Voldemort is canon. Lavendar/Ron is canon. Obviously everyone who's married and/or dates is canon. OBHWF is canon, Harry/Cho is canon. Ships that are not stated as fact in the books are not canon. That means UC ships are good, slash is good, femslash is good. For our purposes, we are not counting JKR's interviews as canon. That means that if you wanted to prompt, say, who knows, Hannah/Neville, you could, because it's not in the text itself.

2. You leave a comment with a pairing and a prompt. You respond to prompts that you like. Your prompt must pertain to a non-canon ship. You may specify a character within that ship if you want the fic written from that characters perspective. You may also specify a timeline if you'd like, or if you want it to take place in the movie!verse.

3. When writing fic, put in your title SHIP - TITLE OF FIC (rating optional). This will help us archive if we later archive things. I don't have time to archive anything right now, but if someone wants to volunteer, we can make that happen.

4. LEAVE FEEDBACK. Comments are the lifeblood of the internet.

5. NO WANK. I'll delete your ass. And we're dealing with ships and I am deletion happy, so watch yourself.

6. There will be spoilers for the movie all over this post, I am sure. You have been warned.

7. Promote this if you please. You can use this code:

For text link:

In the image code box, you can use any of the banners below or the lead banner at the top of the post.

They're all uploaded to tinypic, so you can just copy/paste the source code:

eleusis_walks

superkappa

by

lenina20:

If you want to make your own banner, please post it here.

Have fun!

ETA:

effingeden has graciously offered to archive our prompts and fic here. Thanks so much!

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

(deleted comment)

I love this.

Especially this section:

He is young and inexperienced but he knows you don't need to slip off the rocky cliff, if you walked yourself to the very edge on purpose, dragging her with you, fingers cold as ice, but determined to not let go—never let go—not until he was forced to

So gorgeous.

oh, girl, you are so angry and it shows so much in this and i love it.

The pain, the unrest, I cant stand it. The last paragraph, especially, was made of gold!

(Also, Ive always wondered why everyone assumed that Harry was okay with Ron/Hermione, I always felt he was a little resentful and... sad)

I agree, at the very least as a friend, he must wonder "WHY do you guys always do this? Make up and fight and is so determined to just fit when you obviously don't?"

I mean, I had friends like that and I always ended up throwing my hands up in the air and walking away.

Exactly, it must be exhausting to see these two do their little routine, over and over again.

I always felt he just chose to stay quiet about it all, for reasons he didnt want to or dare think about.

Damn, this is good. So heartbreaking and it makes sense.

I felt Harry was faking his support for Ron/Hermione as well.

hmm, faking isn't the right word. Maybe trying desperately but deep down he doesn't really loke it and it shows. HAHA

thaaaanks for writing this lenina20. I really felt for Harry in the movie. I think it was clear beyond any doubt that he wants/loves Hermione at that point, but he wants Ron to be happy too so he makes the ultimate stupid sacrifice

oh god. harry/hermione and stars will always take over my heart.

this. this and i love it.
just raw, angry, and beautiful. thank you.

This. It's such a beautiful thing. I love this.

Excellent. You've packed a lot of powerful emotions into those few sentences.

Oh, ouch, and wonderful wonderful. ♥

This is lovely, lovely, lovely.

You can feel Harry's anger, frustration and longing. And I can actually see this happening in the movie.
Great job!!!

His answer is wishing for her silence to remain forever within his silence. His answer is fisting his right hand inside his pocket until it hurts, so his fingers don’t come to life and reach out for hand. A new bad habit he can't shake off, any more than he can shake off the shadow of her back, so soft beneath his trembling hands, walking away from him, leaving him behind, standing alone at the edge of a precipice, wanting (even for just one second, he lies he lies he lies) the only thing in the world he is forbidden to want.

Oh my word. Love it. LOVE IT. And I feel so very angry at JKR right now.

Thank you for this ficlet. ♥

You have seriously slain me with this fic. Whenever I read your work I am reminded overwhelmingly of how amazing this ship is.

This is my favorite part:

The silence of his private conversations with Hermione. The silence of his fingers lingering on her skin for one second too long, forbidden, irresistible. He misses the silence of her big glassy eyes, the silence of her sadness, the silence of the way they sometimes looked at each other. She misses the silence of their wonder, the silence of words left unsaid—words left forever unsaid. The silence very rarely broken—once by an insane painful wish.

And then this is made me want to cry

A new bad habit he can't shake off, any more than he can shake off the shadow of her back, so soft beneath his trembling hands, walking away from him, leaving him behind, standing alone at the edge of a precipice, wanting (even for just one second, he lies he lies he lies) the only thing in the world he is forbidden to want.

oh my word *clutches heart*

Great, great, great. This was wonderful. I think the charactersiation was spot on and it was beautifully written. So nice. Thank you for sharing.

that was amazing—i was tearing up kjhfdk

Oh, this is perfect. Exactly I could see this going on in that scene. Beautiful work!

This is amazing and I sincerely hope you consider reposting this somewhere, because it is gorgeous and should be seen by many, not lost in all of these comments.

Sorry for the run-on, there, but it truly is beautiful. And so very sad. </3

Oh my god, the emotions in this fic, my heeeaaarrrttt. This is insanely gorgeous and just such a lovely piece. Thanks for this <3

My heart is shattered. It's okay though because this was beautiful and I loved it.

*CRIES*

HARRY POTTER NON-CANON SHIPS COMMENT FICATHON

Re: I am outside; harry/hermione, pg

Re: I am outside; harry/hermione, pg

Re: I am outside; harry/hermione, pg

Re: I am outside; harry/hermione, pg

Re: I am outside; harry/hermione, pg

Re: I am outside; harry/hermione, pg

Re: I am outside; harry/hermione, pg

Re: I am outside; harry/hermione, pg

Re: I am outside; harry/hermione, pg

Re: I am outside; harry/hermione, pg

Re: I am outside; harry/hermione, pg

Re: I am outside; harry/hermione, pg

Re: I am outside; harry/hermione, pg

Re: I am outside; harry/hermione, pg

Re: I am outside; harry/hermione, pg

Re: I am outside; harry/hermione, pg

Re: I am outside; harry/hermione, pg

Re: I am outside; harry/hermione, pg

Re: I am outside; harry/hermione, pg

Re: I am outside; harry/hermione, pg

Re: I am outside; harry/hermione, pg